Coin renewal
Coin renewal was a medieval fiscal practice in which the sovereign regularly withdrew valid coins from circulation and replaced them with new strikings of poorer quality at a forced unfavourable rate. This system, known in Latin as renovatio monetae, enabled rulers to derive substantial revenue from the coinage regalia.
The system of coin renewal arose in early medieval Europe as a way for sovereigns to profit regularly from holding the coinage right. The first evidence of this practice comes from Poland and Hungary in the 10th century, from where it spread to the Czech lands. The earliest written mention of coin renewal in Bohemia comes from Cosmas's Chronicle, which describes the situation under the reign of Bretislav I and his successors in the 11th century.
The mechanism worked as follows: the sovereign ordered the withdrawal of all circulating denarii and their compulsory exchange for new strikings. The exchange rate was unfavourable: for example, three old coins for two new ones. The withdrawn silver denarii were melted down and restruck with a lower silver content. The difference between the value of the metal received and that issued represented the sovereign's profit. This process was repeated usually once or twice a year, generally at major markets.
Cosmas of Prague captured the dramatic consequences of this practice in his chronicle. In chapter 33 of the first book he states: "No disaster, no plague or mass dying, nor would enemies devastating the whole country by plunder and burning, harm God's people as much as the frequent changing and fraudulent debasement of the coin." These words illustrate the economic devastation that coin renewal caused to the ordinary population.
Under the reign of Premysl Otakar I (1197 to 1230) coin renewal reached its peak. Coins were exchanged up to four times a year at the main markets in Prague, Brno and other towns. The quality of the denarii gradually worsened: while denarii from the beginning of the 12th century contained around 900/1000 silver, by the middle of the 13th century the fineness had fallen to a mere 300 to 400/1000. Such debased coins were known as bracteates.
History
Resistance from the population to this practice was considerable, and so the exchange was enforced with drastic punishments. Cosmas mentions threats of ruin and the furies of hell for those who would try to hide the old coins. Sovereigns ordered house searches and the confiscation of property from those refusing to exchange. Merchants tried to evade the system by using foreign coins or by barter.
In neighbouring lands coin renewal took place with varying intensity. In Bavaria and Austria the system was milder, with exchange once every few years. In Poland and Moravia, by contrast, the practice reached a similar intensity to Bohemia. The Silesian princes even struck special short-term bracteates valid only between two annual fairs.
The end of coin renewal was brought by the monetary reform of Wenceslas II. In 1300 he introduced the Prague groschen as a stable silver coin with a guaranteed content of 3.7 grams of fine silver. The groschen was not renewed and its value remained constant. This reform ended two centuries of economic uncertainty and laid the foundations for the economic flowering of the Czech Kingdom in the 14th century.
Coin renewal had a devastating impact on the economy. Uncertainty regarding the value of money paralysed trade; people tried to get rid of coins as quickly as possible or turned to barter. Prices of goods continuously rose in order to compensate for expected debasement. Savings lost their value, which discouraged the accumulation of capital needed for the development of crafts and trade.
Economic impact and mechanisms
The sovereign's profits from renewal were considerable. With each exchange he gained 25 to 50 per cent of the value of the currency in circulation. In the case of Bohemia, with approximately one million inhabitants and currency worth 100,000 marks of silver, the king could gain as much as 50,000 marks annually. This represented greater income than all other taxes combined.
Technically the exchange took place at designated places during markets. Mint officials checked the weight and authenticity of the coins brought in, then exchanged them for new ones at the set rate. Counterfeiting or evading the exchange was punished by the loss of a hand or by death. Even so, there was large-scale smuggling of higher-quality older coins across borders.