Ultrasonic Testing
Ultrasonic testing is a method of non-destructive testing that verifies the authenticity and internal integrity of coins, bars and other metal objects by means of high-frequency sound waves. It makes it possible to reveal cavities, layering or an inserted foreign core without damaging the surface.
Ultrasonic testing is based on the physical principle of the propagation of sound waves in a material. The wave propagates in metal at a certain speed, which depends on its density and elasticity, and at the interfaces between different materials or at flaws (cracks, cavities, inhomogeneities) part of the energy is reflected. It is precisely from the measurement of transit time and the analysis of reflections that one can infer what is "inside", without it being necessary to cut up or otherwise disturb the object. In industry, ultrasonic testing spread especially in the 20th century, when it became the standard for the inspection of welds, castings and pressure vessels. It gradually became miniaturised and more precise, which enabled its use outside heavy industry too.
Ultrasound entered the area of precious metals and numismatics chiefly as a response to the fact that the inspection of the surface alone no longer always suffices. Modern forgeries can be produced very well, with precise weight and dimensions and sometimes also with a credible appearance of the strike. Particularly risky are situations where the object outwardly is of "genuine" metal, but inside contains other material, or is composed of layers. A typical problem are inserted cores of metals with different density or mechanical properties, or cavities that adjust the weight and "bring the forgery closer" to the original. Here ultrasound has a fundamental advantage: it does not rely only on appearance, but tests the behaviour of the material in volume.
In practice, two main approaches have come to the fore for coins and bars. The first is the measurement of sound velocity and thickness (the time of pulse transit), which can quickly reveal that the material does not correspond to the declared metal. The second is echographic inspection (working with reflections), which makes it possible to capture interfaces inside the object — for example, the place where a surface layer meets a different core. With the development of portable instruments, ultrasound has become usable outside the laboratory as well: at dealers, in auction houses or when receiving investment bars.
History
Ultrasound has thus joined the methods that complement traditional procedures for verifying authenticity. Previously, collectors relied chiefly on weight, diameter, style and sometimes on the "sound" when tapped. Today, more techniques are often combined, because every test has its limits: weight and dimensions can be imitated, magnetism reveals only certain materials, and surface features can be very faithful. Ultrasound has brought the possibility of looking inside without intervention, and is therefore prized especially for precious metals, where a destructive test would mean a loss of value. In numismatics, moreover, it also protects the aesthetic side: a quality coin should not be ground, drilled or "tested by fire" if a gentler route exists.
Ultrasonic testing works with a transducer that emits a short ultrasonic pulse into the metal. This propagates through the material, is reflected from the opposite surface and possibly also from internal interfaces. The instrument measures the time after which the signal returns and, from its shape, assesses whether there is something "extra" inside. With homogeneous metal, the course of the signal tends to be clean and predictable, while layers, cavities or foreign inserts create additional reflections or change the propagation speed. With bars, the test is often very effective, because they have a simple shape and greater thickness, so internal interfaces show up more clearly.
With coins the situation is somewhat more demanding. Relief and variable thickness can worsen the contact of the probe and complicate interpretation, so a suitable measurement spot is used (for example, a flatter section) and often also a contact gel. Ultrasound is very good at revealing "sandwich" constructions and unnatural cavities, but copes less well with very thin layers or with forgeries made of material that has acoustic properties close to the original. In practice, therefore, it gives the best results as part of combined verification: together with weighing and measurement of dimensions, possibly with methods based on electrical conductivity or X-ray fluorescence.
How it works and what it can reveal
The advantage of ultrasound is its gentleness and speed. If the object is handled correctly, it leaves no trace on the surface and the test can be repeated. At the same time, however, it requires correct setting and experience in evaluation, so that common deviations (for example, small irregularities, edge reflections or surface scratches) are not mistaken for an internal defect. With more valuable pieces it is therefore advisable to treat ultrasound as very strong evidence, but not as the only measure of authenticity.